Thanks to the good folks at the Dover Public Library for the work they've put into compiling these helpful lists:
The first link is to a wide variety of lists arranged by subject and age level:
http://www.dover.lib.nh.us/Childrens%27Room/childrenpages/Book%20Lists.htm
This next link has an assortment of lists, from Caldecott and Newbury winners to award-winning recordings for children:
http://www.dover.lib.nh.us/Childrens%27Room/childrenpages/notable.htm
As these are lists from the Dover Public Library, we may not have every title in our collection. Chances are however, that we can find a copy for you, or that we can suggest something similar.
